Roof Prism Vs Porro Prism Binoculars
This is one of those questions we get asked fairly regularly here at Binocular Base, and in all honesty, it’s a difficult one to answer. They both have their pros and cons, and it really is a matter of personal choice. So we have decided to lay all of the facts out in front of you, to help you to make an informed decision.
Table of Contents
What Are Binoculars?
Most people are familiar with binoculars but we’ve decided to start at the very beginning and work forward from there. Put in simple terms, binoculars use various lenses, prisms and other elements to produce a magnified and illuminated image of whatever object you direct them towards.
By the use of 2 parallel tubes with lenses and prism arrangements enclosed, the user can observe with both eyes simultaneously. This gives the user a clearer sense of depth and an almost 3D type image. As opposed to telescopes which use only one eye while keeping the other eye closed.
What Are Prisms?
We all talk about Porro prisms and roof prisms, but what exactly are prisms? According to Dictionary.com a prism is;
- Optics. a transparent solid body, often having triangular bases, used for dispersing light into a spectrum or for reflecting rays of light.
- Geometry. a solid having bases or ends that are parallel, congruent polygons and sides that are parallelograms.
- Crystallography. a form having faces parallel to the vertical axis and intersecting the horizontal axes.
For usage in binoculars we take the first definition concerning optics. Which is probably a fine definition but in plain English, a prism is a block of glass that takes on the role of a mirror. Or acts like a mirror, it is not a mirror because the prisms used in binoculars have no reflective backing.
The prisms work to produce an image by bending the light, they reflect the light entering through the objective lens (the larger lens, the one closest to the object you’re looking at), then amplify the image that is then sent to the eye piece (ocular lens, the smaller one you look through). But that’s only part of what prisms do, they also invert the image (as it would appear upside down if not for the prisms) so you see the image magnified and the correct way up.
What Are Porro Prism Binoculars?
Porro Prism binoculars are named after their inventor Ignazio Porro, who first developed this type of binoculars in Italy in the 1850s. His design has stood the test of time because it’s the same design still used to this day.
They operate by sending the light that enters through the objective lens through a pair of slightly offset prisms. It’s the movement between the prisms that acts to amplify the image and also invert it and it then travels through to the ocular lens.
Porro prism binoculars are easy to identify due to their offset shape (to house the offset prisms). Which gives them a similar appearance to a capital M. As the arrangement of the prisms takes up considerable space, Porro prisms are larger than roof prism binoculars. They are also heavier and due to the shape, harder to completely waterproof. On top of which the offset prism arrangement is easy to knock out of alignment which can be undetected but will lead to eye strain which in turn leads to headaches and migraine.
Having listed their failings, it’s only fair to list their advantages too. Porro prisms have a higher light transmission rate, better depth perception, a wider field of view, and cost less for higher quality binoculars compared to roof prisms.
Reverse Porro Prism Binoculars
With all that’s been said about porro prism binoculars we couldn’t leave the subject without a quick mention about reverse Porro Prism binoculars. These are far more compact than regular Porro prism binoculars, the design allows for great waterproofing and anti-fogging plus they are lighter and easier to carry/pack.
The downside of reverse Porro prism binoculars is they are the largest of the compact types of binoculars, they also have the objective lens too close together which reduces the stereoscopic view, which in turn, affects depth perception. Which is one of the main strengths of regular Porro prisms.
The Pros And Cons Of Porro Prism Binoculars At A Glance
|Advantages Of Porro Prism Binoculars||Disadvantages Of Porro Prism Binoculars|
|Realistic 3D image||Easy to misalign offset prisms|
|Wide field of view||Heavy|
|Better depth perception||Bulky|
|Light transmission at a high rate||Harder to waterproof|
|Cost less for better quality|
What Are Roof Prism Binoculars?
Roof prism binoculars were invented around the beginning of the 20th century . Most roof prism binoculars use one of two prism designs either the Abbe-Koenig prism named after Ernst Karl Abbe and Albert Koenig and patented by Carl Zeiss in 1905. Or the Schmidt-Pechan prism which were invented in 1899. Both types have objective lenses that are roughly in line with the ocular lenses.
They look like a capital H, having two straight, thin lens tubes joined by a central focussing knob. Due to the positioning of the prisms (as the name suggests in the roof of the lens tube), roof prisms are narrower and far more compact than Porro prisms. Roof prisms produce an image which is around 12 to 15% duller than similarly sized Porro prisms.
Roof prisms also need a tighter alignment of optical elements which is termed “collimation” this adds to the already higher expense needed to produce roof prism binoculars. But once the prisms are set in roof prisms, they won’t need re-collimating, unlike Porro prisms which need re-collimation after the slightest of knocks.
Roof prisms also require a special coating to bring the images into phase which is a complicated way of saying that once they’re coated the image you see through the ocular lens is the true image not a split image that reaches the eyes at different times.
Due to the design of roof prism binoculars, they are easy to waterproof and fog proof. This is because all of the necessary components for focussing etc can be easily sealed inside the body of the binoculars. Something that is much harder to achieve with Porro prism binoculars.
Roof prism binoculars are designed to take a rougher handling than Porros and this makes them a great choice for travelling. Another plus for travelling with roof prisms is the size and weight advantage they have over Porros. But as we said earlier that useability comes at a cost.
The Pros And Cons Of Roof Prism Binoculars At A Glance
|The Advantages Or Roof Prism Binoculars||The Disadvantages Of Roof Prism Binoculars|
|Far Stronger (more robust)||Narrower field of view|
|Smaller to carry||Slightly less clarity of image|
|Light weight||Cost more to produce and that cost is passed on to the customer|
|Far easier to waterproof|
A Direct Comparison Of Porro And Roof Prism Binoculars
|Roof Prism Binoculars||Porro Prism Binoculars|
|First produced in 1905||Standard design since 1850s|
|Easy to hold, lightweight and compact||No so easy to hold, heavier and bulky design|
|Far easier to waterproof due to design||Not so easy to waterproof|
|Robust design, unlikely to go out of focussing alignment||Not so durable, very likely to get internal prisms misaligned|
|Higher powered lens available||Less powerful lens available|
|Higher manufacturing costs due to superior quality components||Less expensive to produce, the highest quality will cost less than mid range roof prisms|
|Straight lens tubes due to straight prism alignment||More abstract shape due to offset prism alignment|
|Some models need special tripods or adaptors||Virtually all Porro binoculars can be mounted easily on a standard tripod|
|Less stereoscopic images||More stereoscopic images due to design of body|
|Smaller distance between eyepieces||Wider distance between eyepieces|
|More suited for backpacking, hunting and travelling||More suited for recreational usage, bird watching etc|
|Specially dielectric coated prisms||No need for coating the prisms|
Which Prism Glass Is Best?
We can’t do a fair comparison without mentioning prism glass, this will often be mentioned on the binoculars box but unless you understand the differences, it means little or nothing. You will often notice BAK-4 or BK-7 prism glass, but what does that mean and which is better?
This is the coding for Barium Crown glass and it’s widely considered to be the best type of glass for making prisms. It has a high refractive index and a lower critical angle which basically means it transmits light better, with less light loss due to internal bubbles trapped in the glass due to the manufacturing process.
BK7 is used more often in binoculars than BAK-4, it might have slightly lower quality than BAK-4 but it’s still an optical glass with superb light transmission properties and a few internal imperfections. The imperfections that are present are so small as to be of no influence or worry at all.
How Can You Tell Whether Your Binoculars Use BAK-4 or BK7 Glass Prisms?
The easiest way to tell which glass your binoculars prisms were constructed from is to turn the binoculars upside down. Look through the objective lens at arm’s length and look at the exit pupil. If the image has squared off sides to the general roundness of the image then they have BK7 prisms. If the image shows a true round exit pupil, this indicates BAK-4 prisms which means your binoculars have better light transmission and complete edge to edge sharpness of image.
What’s The Best, Porro Prism Binoculars Or Roof Prism Binoculars?
If after reading all of the facts and figures you’re still undecided on which type of binoculars to buy, it’s hardly surprising. They both have their good and bad points, so it really comes down to what activities you plan to use them for. So let’s look at them from an activity point of view.
Which Type Of Binoculars Are Better For Which Activity?
|Activity||Best Type Of Binoculars|
|Theatre Or Opera/Concert||Roof Prism|
|Sporting Events||Porro Prism|
|Bird Watching/Wildlife||Either Type (your preference)|
|Hunting||Either Type (Your Preference)|
|Whale Watching||Marine Binoculars*|
*Marine binoculars are designed specifically for taking on boats at sea and any other water based activities (see below)
As well as the main two types of binoculars, there are also binoculars specifically designed for certain activities. Marine binoculars have a wider than usual ocular lens and a low to midsize magnification. Low magnification will prevent a shaky image, as any magnification above 10x can cause a shaky image due the natural shake we all have, which is exaggerated to extreme measures above 10x. As boats move anyway a lower magnification is best and we would recommend no greater than 7x magnification. As for the objective lens size, 50mm objective lens diameter will allow plenty of light to enter the binoculars to create a brighter image.
Marine binoculars are usually rubber coated to protect the casing and to stop the binoculars from rolling around. They are also waterproofed, fog proof and many will float if dropped into the water. But it still pays to invest in a floating strap which wraps over the binocular straps and keeps the binoculars afloat if you were to drop them over the side of the boat.
Marine binoculars tend to be more expensive than regular binoculars but if you are a regular boat user they are well worth investing in.
As you can see. There are as many similarities between both of the main types of binoculars as there are differences. We are confident that whichever type of binocular you ultimately choose, they will give you many years of viewing pleasure.
Frequently Asked Questions
Roof prism and Porro prism binoculars have both positives and negatives. At the end of the day, it boils down to personal preference.
Roof prism binoculars are more compact, smaller, easier to waterproof, and weigh less than Porro prism binoculars.
There are 2 pairs of prisms in each lens tube of porro prism binoculars.
Dach prism is the German name for a roof prism.